IM Landscape Growth Podcast

Stop Chasing AI Visibility Scores: Mick Selman & Aaron Towlson, Intrigue Media

Episode Summary

Rob Murray sits down with Intrigue Media’s Mick Selman and Aaron Towlson to cut through the AI SEO noise and explain what actually earns trust with Google and AI tools: the EEAT framework, real backlinks, and consistent content. They also debunk AI visibility scores as an unreliable metric landscapers shouldn't pay to fix.

Episode Notes

00:29 Rob introduces Mick Selman and Aaron Towlson.
01:07 Mick and Aaron explain their roles: Mick handles SEO strategy and research, Aaron applies it with clients.
02:10 Why this episode exists: a flood of AI SEO noise and questionable AI-generated SEO audits.
03:02 The two audiences every business writes for: robots and people.
03:14 What it means to earn a robot's trust, and why Google's guidelines still lead the pack.
03:37 EEAT defined: experience, expertise, authoritativeness, trustworthiness.
04:38 Aaron's reframe: Google is just trying to answer people's questions well.
05:38 The AI slop problem and why volume of content isn't the goal.
07:13 The biggest AI content mistake: hitting play on a tool and never reviewing the output.
08:01 Better input equals better output. Feed AI tools real experience, testimonials, and specifics.
09:06 What experience actually looks like in a blog post, not just years in business.
10:33 Why experience and content compound like an investment the earlier you start.
11:09 The case for starting SEO now even when the payoff is a year or two out.
13:11 Google Ads as the hit, SEO as the cure. Why SEO is a long term strategy, not a quick fix.
14:12 Authority score explained, and the tools that measure it: SEMrush, Ahrefs, Moz.
15:13 What separates a lead-generating authority score from a weak one.
15:57 The three ingredients of authority score: traffic, backlinks, and natural link profile.
17:36 How to actually move the needle: create reasons for people to visit and make the site easy to find.
19:00 Why domain authority plays differently for local landscapers than for national SaaS brands.
20:32 Social media's real role in SEO: more places for people, and AI tools, to find you.
24:29 Why backlinks matter and why most clients ignore them before working with IM Landscape.
24:50 The honest answer on backlinks: earn them with great content, or pay for them carefully.
28:32 The pillar blog and supporting blog content model, localized project by project.
30:37 AI visibility scores debunked as an unreliable, unregulated metric.
32:17 Where real AI visibility data will actually come from: Search Console and Bing.
33:44 The AI readiness checklist mirrors EEAT: helpful content, site structure, backlinks, and buzz.
35:02 Priority one for AI readiness: make sure your site is indexable and check it in Search Console.
36:35 Mick's number one starting move for landscapers: post your own content, consistently.
37:18 The gym analogy: twenty minutes a day beats fifteen hours once.
38:06 Where to go deeper: Google's own EEAT documentation as a starting point.